Editorial was misleading, insulting

Regarding “America’s monster” (Our Turn editorial, Reporter, Nov. 17):

This may be the worst editorial I have ever read. Inaccurate, misleading, illogical, insulting.

The title is misleading. What about the massacre in Norway in 2011? The November 2015 attack in Paris? Both happened despite some of the most restrictive gun laws anywhere. Just two examples.

He didn’t mention the “truck murders” in France and more recently in New York. No guns involved in those.

And we should think like Hercule Poirot – an entertaining but fictitious character? Right.

The author presents a few statistics. But this is such a complex subject, no one (or two) statistics begins to describe the situation.

And such bizarre reasoning:

How does he get from the “… good guy with a gun …” to this “just world fallacy …?”

I’m mystified by that one.

I do not know a rational person who thinks that either murder or rape victims somehow deserve their fate. And you say the NRA and President Trump use this twisted line of reasoning? Insulting.

Is he joking when he writes “… arming yourself will not keep you, or your loved ones, safe from the terrorist … the mugger … the abuser … the child”… ? The child?

What?

As to self-defense, if he did any research at all, then he knows that people frequently defend themselves and their families with firearms. Can they prevent all such attacks? No, but preventing some is a life saver. Not fallacy, Mr. Stills, reality.

I am disappointed that the Reporter would print such a piece of trash. But, then, I guess we get what we pay for.

– Theodore L. Reinhart

More in Letters to the Editor

Trump is making America great again

Though not exactly word for word, but point by point, I agree… Continue reading

Why not investigate Joe Fain rape accusation?

The last two Auburn Reporters reported about the investigation into the rape… Continue reading

Auburn needs to rebuild its downtown core

What to do with the iconic Auburn Avenue Theater? Bulldoze it and… Continue reading

Where are our leaders?

Our nation and the world cannot understand what is happening to the… Continue reading

I-1631? Just another government money grab

I thought the Reporter did a decent job of breaking down the… Continue reading

Thanks to Gilbert and all that he does for others

Thank you for doing a story on the very deserving Curt Gilbert… Continue reading

Race for Congress: Fresh Face vis-a-vis Old Pol

Electing Kim Schrier will bring to the office “pluses” sorely needed in… Continue reading

Don’t be misled, vote yes on I-1631

Let’s dig into the “special interests” that wrote and support I-1631. These… Continue reading

Dino has my vote for Congress

Watching the debate between Dino Rossi and Kim Schrier on YouTube was… Continue reading

I-1639 is a bad law that attacks our rights

If you value your civil rights, then please vote no on I-1639.… Continue reading

I-1631 Opponents do not care about you or your family

In the Auburn Reporter, Don Brunell wrote a piece, “Carbon fee hurts… Continue reading

Fain works, solves many of our problems

Please join me in supporting Joe Fain in the upcoming Senate election.… Continue reading