Editorial was misleading, insulting

Regarding “America’s monster” (Our Turn editorial, Reporter, Nov. 17):

This may be the worst editorial I have ever read. Inaccurate, misleading, illogical, insulting.

The title is misleading. What about the massacre in Norway in 2011? The November 2015 attack in Paris? Both happened despite some of the most restrictive gun laws anywhere. Just two examples.

He didn’t mention the “truck murders” in France and more recently in New York. No guns involved in those.

And we should think like Hercule Poirot – an entertaining but fictitious character? Right.

The author presents a few statistics. But this is such a complex subject, no one (or two) statistics begins to describe the situation.

And such bizarre reasoning:

How does he get from the “… good guy with a gun …” to this “just world fallacy …?”

I’m mystified by that one.

I do not know a rational person who thinks that either murder or rape victims somehow deserve their fate. And you say the NRA and President Trump use this twisted line of reasoning? Insulting.

Is he joking when he writes “… arming yourself will not keep you, or your loved ones, safe from the terrorist … the mugger … the abuser … the child”… ? The child?

What?

As to self-defense, if he did any research at all, then he knows that people frequently defend themselves and their families with firearms. Can they prevent all such attacks? No, but preventing some is a life saver. Not fallacy, Mr. Stills, reality.

I am disappointed that the Reporter would print such a piece of trash. But, then, I guess we get what we pay for.

– Theodore L. Reinhart

More in Letters to the Editor

Dreaming of a white Christmas

The weather outside may not be frightful, but it is still the… Continue reading

Democracy’s cornerstone: a free press

Every time Trump proclaims something as “fake-news,” he is attacking truth and… Continue reading

Big bill, little return

I just got a bill on my car license tabs. What a… Continue reading

Economic collapse: remember ‘08?

Even if you do remember 1993 (“About our business climate today? Remember… Continue reading

Election aftermath: sore losers?

About a week before election day, I emailed Mayor Nancy Backus and… Continue reading

Consider whom, what you are supporting

I support the letter, “We need to participate as voters, citizens” (Oct.… Continue reading

Rylands ready to lead District 31

Having worked with Michelle Rylands in our schools and on the Auburn… Continue reading

Thank you

I wish to acknowledge my appreciation for the free knife-sharpening service for… Continue reading

Let’s live in peace

Over centuries, people have knelt for different reasons: honor, respect, love, devotion,… Continue reading

Backus is the only choice for Auburn

I have been an employee for the city of Auburn for 22… Continue reading

Largo is the choice for mayor

Just a few days left to make a difference. Let’s put Deputy… Continue reading

Stay with a good thing, re-elect Backus

Conventional wisdom says when you find a good thing, you should stick… Continue reading