Editorial was misleading, insulting

Regarding “America’s monster” (Our Turn editorial, Reporter, Nov. 17):

This may be the worst editorial I have ever read. Inaccurate, misleading, illogical, insulting.

The title is misleading. What about the massacre in Norway in 2011? The November 2015 attack in Paris? Both happened despite some of the most restrictive gun laws anywhere. Just two examples.

He didn’t mention the “truck murders” in France and more recently in New York. No guns involved in those.

And we should think like Hercule Poirot – an entertaining but fictitious character? Right.

The author presents a few statistics. But this is such a complex subject, no one (or two) statistics begins to describe the situation.

And such bizarre reasoning:

How does he get from the “… good guy with a gun …” to this “just world fallacy …?”

I’m mystified by that one.

I do not know a rational person who thinks that either murder or rape victims somehow deserve their fate. And you say the NRA and President Trump use this twisted line of reasoning? Insulting.

Is he joking when he writes “… arming yourself will not keep you, or your loved ones, safe from the terrorist … the mugger … the abuser … the child”… ? The child?

What?

As to self-defense, if he did any research at all, then he knows that people frequently defend themselves and their families with firearms. Can they prevent all such attacks? No, but preventing some is a life saver. Not fallacy, Mr. Stills, reality.

I am disappointed that the Reporter would print such a piece of trash. But, then, I guess we get what we pay for.

– Theodore L. Reinhart


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@auburn-reporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.auburn-reporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Letters to the Editor

Send your letters to editor@auburn-reporter.com
Tribute to my first-grade teacher, Francelle Calkins

I believe 1946 was her first year of teaching at Washington Elementary… Continue reading

Some good advice in the fight against infection

School closings, sports event cancellations, food hoarding. … We live in a… Continue reading

Isn’t time to re-evaluate our conditions?

Mayor Nancy Backus‘ coronavirus emergency proclamation should serve as notice how quickly… Continue reading

Thanks for an informative talk

I’m grateful to Congresswoman Kim Schrier for holding a town hall about… Continue reading

Let’s set the record straight

A letter published in the Auburn Reporter ron Feb. 28, “Stop the… Continue reading

A good approach to car tab fees

Charles Sweet’s letter suggesting analyzing and shifting budget needs before passing a… Continue reading

Stop the scare tactics, support senior benefits

There is absolutely no good reason for politicians (mostly conservative-Republicans) to scare… Continue reading

We need evidence, measures when considering car tab fee reduction

Most, if not all, state and local government programs can be tested.… Continue reading

Asking voters to support us

Mountain View Fire and Rescue is proud to provide fire and life… Continue reading

Auburn could do more to save planet

What is Auburn doing to help stop the worldwide environmental crisis? Why… Continue reading

Democratic mayors fail to silence city shootings

Frank Shiers’ political cartoon (of Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan, Kent Reporter, Jan.… Continue reading

Auburn schools need the best; support levies

On Feb. 11, the Auburn School District has two very important replacement… Continue reading