Guilty until proven innocent

Under the shadow of Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s case, I am a survivor of false claims of domestic violence.

According to my Google search, about 16 percent of rape/abuse cases are reported. Wiktionary says, “The FBI Crime Report in 1996 and U.S. Department of Justice in 1997 stated 28 percent of rape accusations in the U.S. were regarded as unfounded or false.” That means over half of such charges are false.

Dr. Christine Blasey Ford testified that the letter she wrote, accusing Judge Kavanaugh of attempted rape, was turned over to Congresswoman Anna Eshoo and Sen. Dianne Feinstein before Kavanaugh was nominated for the Supreme Court. That means Eshoo and Feinstein withheld evidence from the FBI while the background investigation of Kavanaugh was ongoing.

An attorney reports that U.S. Code Chapter 73 says the concealment of physical evidence is obstruction of justice, and an FBI agent over the phone told me that is a crime. Therefore, Eshoo and Feinstein could be charged with a crime for failing to hand over Ford’s letter to the FBI.

Continuing my Google search, I found this. “Once a false accusation has been made – particularly an emotionally laden one – normal human emotional response to being falsely accused (such as fear, anger or denial of the accusation) may be misinterpreted as evidence of guilt.” We have seen a recent example of that definition in action.

It also states, “A false allegation can occur as a result of faulty interviewing techniques or when suggestive questioning is involved.”

Have Ford’s counseling records been subpoenaed?

During a counseling session, Ford claimed she told her husband and her counselor about the attempted rape she experienced while in high school. None of the attorneys on the Senate Judiciary Committee, some of them prosecutors, mentioned the Safe Families Act of 1997, which states that laws of all 50 states require a therapist to contact authorities when their client reports a rape/abuse.

Did Ford’s therapist use faulty interviewing techniques, thereby leading Ford to a false accusation? And did she/he not report Ford’s claim of sexual abuse, thereby risking the possibility of losing her/his license to practice? Or did Ford not report the incident, which might explain why her husband did not step up to substantiate her story?

Only her counseling documents know the truth. And so should we all.

– Gerald McBreen, past president, Washington chapter, Fathers United For Equal Rights

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Letters to the Editor

Send your letters to
Tribute to my first-grade teacher, Francelle Calkins

I believe 1946 was her first year of teaching at Washington Elementary… Continue reading

Thoughts on recent tragedies | Letter to the editor
Thoughts on recent tragedies | Letter to the editor

It is impossible to ignore the tragedies we have experienced in the… Continue reading

Some good advice in the fight against infection

School closings, sports event cancellations, food hoarding. … We live in a… Continue reading

Isn’t time to re-evaluate our conditions?

Mayor Nancy Backus‘ coronavirus emergency proclamation should serve as notice how quickly… Continue reading

Thanks for an informative talk

I’m grateful to Congresswoman Kim Schrier for holding a town hall about… Continue reading

Let’s set the record straight

A letter published in the Auburn Reporter ron Feb. 28, “Stop the… Continue reading

A good approach to car tab fees
A good approach to car tab fees

Charles Sweet’s letter suggesting analyzing and shifting budget needs before passing a… Continue reading

Stop the scare tactics, support senior benefits

There is absolutely no good reason for politicians (mostly conservative-Republicans) to scare… Continue reading

We need evidence, measures when considering car tab fee reduction
We need evidence, measures when considering car tab fee reduction

Most, if not all, state and local government programs can be tested.… Continue reading

Asking voters to support us

Mountain View Fire and Rescue is proud to provide fire and life… Continue reading

Auburn could do more to save planet

What is Auburn doing to help stop the worldwide environmental crisis? Why… Continue reading

Democratic mayors fail to silence city shootings

Frank Shiers’ political cartoon (of Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan, Kent Reporter, Jan.… Continue reading