I-1631 Opponents do not care about you or your family

In the Auburn Reporter, Don Brunell wrote a piece, “Carbon fee hurts business and families,” (Oct. 12), where he argues that cutting carbon emissions is a laudable goal, but that this particular carbon tax is too harmful to soccer moms, small produce companies and local supermarkets.

After surveying a series of inflated costs, Brunell concludes with the wish that backers of I-1631 consider revenue neutral proposals like I-732, the revenue-neutral carbon tax that failed in 2016. Yet the very organization that Brunell used to lead, the Association of Washington Business (AWB), ran a series of ads against I-732 that recapitulates – almost point for point – the same arguments Brunell makes against I-1631.

In short, no carbon tax exists that Brunell could support because he simply does not support actual, real carbon taxes and only raises other carbon taxes as a means to undermine the current proposals on the table.

Brunell and the AWB and Rob McKenna (Chevron employee) and the oil companies who are funding “no on I-1631” do not care about you, your family or the future of Washington state. They care about protecting their investments in dirty fossil fuels, and they care so much that they’re willing to let your child get asthma, watch peoples’ homes go up in smoke, poison the air and the earth, let the seas swamp historic Washington towns, and let famines and disasters kill millions of people around the world.

In November, we have the chance to create something different. I-1631 reorients our economy away from fossil fuels, placing a modest, but rising fee on fossil fuels (analysis suggests that the costs per family per month are around $10). We can grow an economy that’s not based on poison, but on electrification, clean energy, high tech and balancing our relationship with nature.

In short, there’s a future worth having. Don’t let the oil company profits and their paid stooges keep us from it.

– Nathan Schumer




Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@auburn-reporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.auburn-reporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Letters to the Editor

Send your letters to editor@auburn-reporter.com
Tribute to my first-grade teacher, Francelle Calkins

I believe 1946 was her first year of teaching at Washington Elementary… Continue reading

Thoughts on recent tragedies | Letter to the editor
Thoughts on recent tragedies | Letter to the editor

It is impossible to ignore the tragedies we have experienced in the… Continue reading

Some good advice in the fight against infection

School closings, sports event cancellations, food hoarding. … We live in a… Continue reading

Isn’t time to re-evaluate our conditions?

Mayor Nancy Backus‘ coronavirus emergency proclamation should serve as notice how quickly… Continue reading

Thanks for an informative talk

I’m grateful to Congresswoman Kim Schrier for holding a town hall about… Continue reading

Let’s set the record straight

A letter published in the Auburn Reporter ron Feb. 28, “Stop the… Continue reading

A good approach to car tab fees
A good approach to car tab fees

Charles Sweet’s letter suggesting analyzing and shifting budget needs before passing a… Continue reading

Stop the scare tactics, support senior benefits

There is absolutely no good reason for politicians (mostly conservative-Republicans) to scare… Continue reading

We need evidence, measures when considering car tab fee reduction
We need evidence, measures when considering car tab fee reduction

Most, if not all, state and local government programs can be tested.… Continue reading

Asking voters to support us

Mountain View Fire and Rescue is proud to provide fire and life… Continue reading

Auburn could do more to save planet

What is Auburn doing to help stop the worldwide environmental crisis? Why… Continue reading

Democratic mayors fail to silence city shootings

Frank Shiers’ political cartoon (of Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan, Kent Reporter, Jan.… Continue reading