What gives ‘health food’ a bad name? | Gustafson

  • Wednesday, November 8, 2017 4:30pm
  • Life

By Timi Gustafson, R.D./For the Reporter

The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) has recently announced the government’s intention to ease school lunch regulations that were introduced under the former administration.

As a reason for the rollback the agency cited students’ complaints about perhaps healthier but also blander and less appealing food choices offered in cafeterias following the new guidelines. Also, food manufacturers and purveyors have lobbied hard for a relaxation of what they call overly restrictive and burdensome rules imposed on them by the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010.

The perception that healthier foods are less palatable, of course, is neither new nor limited to schoolchildren. Research has long shown how fat, salt and sugar trigger pleasure responses in the human brain and add to the enjoyment of eating. Eliminating or reducing these ingredients obviously will send out signals that something is amiss. That may be one explanation.

Another is that most people don’t like making changes, especially when it comes to highly personal matters like their eating habits. So, being told that certain preferences are no longer acceptable and should be abandoned is not a particularly welcomed message. Even when detrimental outcomes are in plain sight – like the ever-worsening obesity crisis – change is hard to come by and will likely be resisted.

Also, much of what drives eating behavior is based on intuitive and emotional factors rather than rational decision-making, and is not always readily understood.

For instance, when McDonald’s famously tried to introduce a leaner version of its regular line of hamburgers in the early 1990s, called the “McLean,” it failed miserably despite the fact that it was not only healthier but also found to be tastier in blind tests. As the company’s analyses showed, the name itself may have connoted for customers with somewhat lower quality, diminished value, or deviation from established expectations – and so it was soon pulled from the menu.

That may also shed some light on the question why the flood of dietary information provided to the public in recent years has done so little to improve overall nutritional health. The obstacles don’t only lie in conveying basic facts in intelligible, use-able ways, but also in the recipients’ emotional responses to the warnings and recommendations that are being issued.

Even small nuances in wording can make a difference. As one study from Stanford University in California demonstrated, people react differently to various descriptions of food. For example, simple, matter-of-fact listings of ingredients did the least for participants to become enthused about the meals they could choose from. By contrast, imaginative and colorful renditions (as typically performed by wait staff at high-end restaurants) made them more curious and open to trying unfamiliar dishes.

Because there is this widespread perception that healthy eating has to be boring and plain, using descriptive words to highlight the amazing flavor profiles many health-promoting food options posses can have a positive impact, said Vandana Sheth, a Los Angeles-based dietitian and media spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (AND). Health care professionals, educators and parents should consider using such concepts to encourage healthy eating habits and make their recommendations more appealing, she added.

Timi Gustafson R.D. is a registered dietitian, newspaper columnist, and blogger. For more articles on nutrition, health and lifestyle, visit her blog, “Food and Health with Timi Gustafson R.D.” (timigustafson.com). You can follow Timi on Twitter, on Facebook and Google+.

More in Life

Green River College cast presents ‘Peter and the Starcatcher’

Jump aboard the Neverland for a voyage to Rundoon, an island of… Continue reading

Experience the holidays with Pacific Ballroom Dance’s Let Love Lead

Pacific Ballroom Dance (PBD), a local nonprofit dance studio out of Auburn,… Continue reading

Auburn-area public library program listings | Fall 2017

Auburn Library, 1102 Auburn Way S. 253- 931-3018. Library events include: CHILDREN… Continue reading

Red Cross offers top 10 driving and other travel tips for the holidays

Travelers should plan ahead and expect delays as they head to destinations

Have breakfast with Santa on Dec. 9; registration open

Auburn Parks, Arts & Recreation hosts a Breakfast with Santa on Saturday,… Continue reading

Dozen Rainier Youth Choirs members accepted into 2018 NW ACDA Honor Choir

A dozen Rainier Youth Choirs members have been accepted to sing in… Continue reading

Corestar Pilates’ Thanksgiving Day Sampler returns Nov. 23

Exercise program and nonperishable food drive open to the public

Rainier Youth Choirs to perform on Argosy Christmas Ship

The Rainier Youth Choirs group, Colla Voce, performs on the lead boat… Continue reading

Ask Dr. Ulissey | November Q/A

Q. I recently saw a celebrity news story indicating a breast MRI… Continue reading

Jet City Improv brings blend of comedy to the Ave

Jet City Improv – a fast-paced and fun audience participation comedy show… Continue reading

Almost Human – Kiss Tribute to play the Ave

Almost Human – a Pacific Northwest’s Kiss tribute band – comes to… Continue reading

Prostate cancer: To test or not to test?

By MultiCare Health System It’s a simple blood test that can help… Continue reading